【will cedar keep moths away】U.S. Supreme Court justices question human rights claims against Nestle and Cargill
By Lawrence Hurley
WASHINGTON,will cedar keep moths away Dec 1(Reuters) - U.S. Supreme Court justices on Tuesday appeared wary of barring lawsuits against American companies over alleged human rights abuses abroad but signaled they could toss out a case accusing Cargill Inc and a Nestle SA subsidiary of knowingly helping perpetuate slavery at Ivory Coast cocoa farms.
The two companies are asking the nine justices to reverse a lower court ruling that allowed the lawsuit, brought on behalf of former child slaves from Mali who worked at the farms, filed against them in 2005 to proceed.
The case concerns a 1789 U.S. law called the Alien Tort Statute that lets non-U.S. citizens seek damages in American courts in certain instances. The business community has long sought to limit corporate liability under this law.
Some justices questioned whether the lawsuit actually made clear that company officials knew that the farms involved used child slavery.
"After 15 years, is it too much to ask that you allege specifically that the defendants ... who are before us here, specifically knew that forced child labor was being used on the farms or farm cooperatives with which they did business?" conservative Justice Samuel Alito asked.
The lawsuits targeted the U.S. subsidiary of Swiss-based Nestle, the world's biggest food producer, and commodities trader Cargill, one of the largest privately held U.S. companies.
The plaintiffs accused the companies of aiding and abetting human rights violations through their active involvement in purchasing Ivory Coast cocoa and turning a blind eye to the use of slave labor on the farms despite being aware of the practice in order to keep cocoa prices low.
A federal district court in Los Angeles dismissed the lawsuit twice, most recently in 2017. That court found that the claims were barred by recent Supreme Court decisions that made it harder for plaintiffs to sue corporations in U.S. courts for alleged violations overseas.
The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2018 revived the claims, citing the allegations that the companies provided "personal spending money" to local farmers to guarantee the cheapest source of cocoa. The 9th Circuit found that the payments were akin to kickbacks and that the low price of cocoa was dependant upon the child slave labor.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business interests backed the two companies in the case, as did President Donald Trump's administration.
The Supreme Court in 2013 and 2018 cases curbed the ability of plaintiffs to sue corporations in U.S. courts under the Alien Tort Statute for overseas human rights violations. The court said in those rulings that there needed to be a strong connection between the alleged conduct and actions that took place in the United States. But the court did not definitively rule that companies can never be sued under that law.
Since the 2018 ruling, which was 5-4, the court has shifted further to the right with the appointment by President Donald Trump of conservative justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. (Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham)
View comments
-
Do companies sometimes 'ghost' job applicants? Ask HRWere Hedge Funds Wrong About Crowding Into RealPage, Inc. (RP)?ICEsoft To Host Investor Call To Present Q3 Financial Results And To Provide A General Business UpdateGreen Dot: 3Q Earnings SnapshotWhy Is Vornado (VNO) Up 1.7% Since Last Earnings Report?The Returns At Treatt (LON:TET) Provide Us With Signs Of What's To ComeStifel Financial Appoints Kathleen Brown Lead Independent DirectorIs There Now An Opportunity In Sotherly Hotels Inc. (NASDAQ:SOHO)?AT&T Stock Falls 4%George Floyd protests recall earlier tensions, promises of economic change
下一篇:Bullish Near-Term Prospects for Insurance Brokerage Industry
- ·Aptose to Hold Corporate Update Sunday, December 6th
- ·Market Sentiment Improves As Investors Pin Hopes on G7 Action
- ·Imagine Owning ImmunoPrecise Antibodies (CVE:IPA) And Wondering If The 44% Share Price Slide Is Justified
- ·Sonoco Implementing Price Increases for All Rigid Paper Containers and Closures
- ·Nio Deliveries Jump 109% In November, Boosts Production Capacity To Keep Pace With Rising Demand
- ·LIVE BLOG: How businesses are responding to coronavirus outbreak
- ·Is It Smart To Buy Garmin Ltd. (NASDAQ:GRMN) Before It Goes Ex-Dividend?
- ·Pence will meet cruise industry officials Saturday on coronavirus
- ·Crown Crafts, Inc. to Announce Results for Fiscal 2020 Fourth Quarter
- ·Equitrans Midstream Corporation (ETRN) Stock Moves -1.99%: What You Should Know
- ·Estimating The Intrinsic Value Of The Hain Celestial Group, Inc. (NASDAQ:HAIN)
- ·3 Consumer Cyclical Mutual Funds to Grab in December
- ·TUI Strikes Compensation Deal With Boeing Over 737 MAX Jets
- ·Market Sentiment Improves As Investors Pin Hopes on G7 Action
- ·Antibodies, Protein-based Vaccines, Anti-virals, and Cell-based Therapies to Lead the Development of COVID-19 Treatment Pipeline- Exclusive Report by Meticulous Research®
- ·Cytokinetics (CYTK) Reports Q4 Loss, Misses Revenue Estimates
- ·Were Hedge Funds Right About Mostly Avoiding Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc. (MMC)?
- ·AUD/USD Forecast: Bottomed At 0.6038, At Risk Of Losing The 0.6000 Level
- ·Buying a House? 4 Things to Take Off Your Must-Have List Now
- ·Business owners contend with threat, reality of coronavirus
- ·The Global Military Ground Robot Market is expected to grow by $ 42.08 bn during 2020-2024 progressing at a CAGR of 27% during the forecast period
- ·Global stocks tumble as US-China tensions escalate
- ·Clarivate Analytics Plc (CCC) Q1 Earnings and Revenues Miss Estimates
- ·Is AquaBounty Technologies (NASDAQ:AQB) Using Too Much Debt?
- ·Platinum Group Metals Ltd. Completes At-The-Market Offering
- ·Recap: Mallinckrodt Q1 Earnings
- ·IIOT-OXYS, Provides Business Update on COVID-19
- ·Culp: Q2 Earnings Insights
- ·Bank of Baroda rolls back charges after public outcry
- ·Big cash holdings in Europe signal unease over stock market outlook
- ·Stocks adding to biggest one day gain on stimulus hopes
- ·Imagine Owning ImmunoPrecise Antibodies (CVE:IPA) And Wondering If The 44% Share Price Slide Is Justified
- ·Unknown gunmen kill three in daylight in Afghan capital Kabul
- ·How Much Is Live Nation Entertainment, Inc. (NYSE:LYV) CEO Getting Paid?
- ·Moving Average Crossover Alert: Tenable
- ·GBP/USD Price Forecast – British Pound Continues to Struggle at Same Level